An article about the suspensions has appeared in the New Statesman’s blog page.
Cross-posted from the New Statesman blog:
In recent days I have begun to think this but now I am completely convinced: The only possible next step for the resistance to this decision and its aftermath is legal action against the administration.
The administration has made clear that there are no depths it will not stoop to in order to crush entirely peaceful dissent. It is willing to evade, delay, go to the High Court, spread disinformation, lie and even suspend (and, it seems likely, expel) entirely innocent staff and students with no semblance of due process or reason (let alone justice) whatsoever. Brian Leiter commented on his blog that this sort of behaviour from an institution in the US would result in law suits being filed – and won. John Protevi in his email to the administrators mentioned the possibility of financial, legal and political action from the relevant professional organisations.
It might be about time for philosophers and other concerned citizens to put their hands in their pockets and set up a legal fund (particularly for the cases of students who may be expelled but also for resisting the closure as a whole).
So long as this fight remains legally asymmetrical (i.e. one side have lawyers and the other side don’t) it will continue to be a situation where the big institution can unilaterally bully and intimidate with impunity. It is sad that protest alone is so impotent without establishing legal connections but that is how it is, it seems.
Also, a petition should be formed and circulated allowing people to declare that they are completely and totally boycotting Middlesex until the decision is reversed, students and staff are reinstated and unequivocal apologies are issued (if there is no such thing set up already). They haven’t responded to countless declarations of outrage but they might respond to being told that a whole swarm of senior academics won’t have anything to do with the “University” for the rest of their careers and will do everything in their power to discourage others from doing so if they don’t retreat from their present position.
Philosophy at Middlesex is not the first case of this kind and it won’t be the last but it could well be a tipping point. The fight simply must be won.
I could not agree more, though I realise that the setting up of an independent administration to manage an international boycott, a legal fund, and a successful outcome, as well as more frequent – and more effective web publicity – is a tall order indeed. My sense is that existing legal bodies (a co-operation of Unions) should take it on as a matter of urgency. I have to say that I’m shocked that the importance of this situation has not yet been grasped as the test-case it so clearly is. If properly grasped, the fundamental rights which one (only) assumes apply to educational values could be made firm in law.
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:
You are commenting using your WordPress.com account.
( Log Out /
You are commenting using your Google account.
( Log Out /
You are commenting using your Twitter account.
( Log Out /
You are commenting using your Facebook account.
( Log Out /
Connecting to %s
Notify me of new comments via email.
Notify me of new posts via email.